Faulkner vs. Twain

Both Faulkner and Twain have been given credit for the advice, “kill your darlings”, but in reality both probably said and practiced it. For us, it isn’t so important who said it as that we listen to it. There are a lot of ways to look at it. Does it mean you have to cull your best passages in the interest of word count or concision? Probably not. Does it mean be willing to cull those things which may not fit this particular piece but have worth or value for another piece or another time? More likely.

My best lesson in the art of kill your darlings came during grad school. I wrote a story, Murphy’s Meadow, which was a fantasy about a young man who struggled with the consequences of his actions. For almost a year, I wrote draft after draft of the piece watching it get better and better. I began to actually hope I could sell it. There was one huge problem with it. The story had morphed over those drafts and the opening fantasy scenes were juxtaposed against the harsh realism of the scenes that followed. My professor was quite frank. “The opening section has to go. The story actually begins here, with Thad’s jail intro.”

I loved my story’s fantastic beginning. My critique group loved that beginning. We fought this reality. By fight, I mean we revised and revised trying to force the fantasy part to work with the realism. I only set it aside to finish my thesis. When I finished grad school, I began looking at which stories were ready to submit. Murphy’s was one of the first because it was several drafts in. Reading it after months away proved my professor was right. I had to kill my darling. I cut those scenes and placed them in my “parking lot” for possible use in another story. Murphy’s Meadow became Branded in Gray and sold to the first journal I submitted it to.

“Killing my darlings” will never be my favorite thing to do. I won’t even pretend it isn’t painful. However, the payoff is more than worth it. What about you? Have you had to “kill your darlings?” Or are you clinging with your fingertips?


Filed under Writing

6 responses to “Faulkner vs. Twain

  1. Since I’m revising right now, I’m having to kill some darlings. But I comfort myself with the idea that I’m not getting rid of them permanently–I can always use them again in another story.

  2. Yes, I’ve had to kill my darlings before, and it’s so painful! But necessary.

  3. I have not yet got far enough with an MS that I had to, but I know my time is coming – thank you for reminding us that everyone has to go through it because everyone needs to!!

  4. LOL! I’ve just killed the “darling” first line of my WIP after fighting for it for three years. Oh, yes, I feel the pain. ; )

  5. Regina Linton

    I don’t mind killing my darlings if it is necessary.

  6. I usually don’t have a problem, especially after some “cool off” time from the actual story.

    However, I’ve started experimenting with Flash Fiction lately, and that’s a darling massacre every time! If you want to practice your tolerance for it, try your hand at writing a 100 word story!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s